Title – Femininity and Masculinity: Gender Issues By – Arelis Ruiz Primary Subject – Other Secondary Subjects – Language Arts Grade Level – 11-12
| Femininity & Masculinity – Gender Issues Club |
| Club Type: Critical thinking
Eligibility: Teacher recommendation required
Meetings: Once a week |
Introducing the F & M Club:
- As a critical thinking club, the F & M Club will provide relatable resources through which students can practice abstract reasoning in their quest to understanding gender related topics.
- Topics covered throughout the course of this club are mainly issues that stem, in one way or another, out of sexism.
- Through the F & M Club, students will exercise their ability take an objective point of view in the discussion and understanding of heavy, and at times, emotionally stimulating topics.
- Students will develop an eye for recognizing gender issues in the media through its portrayal in music videos, advertisements, political cartoons, and writings.
- Incorporated resources, thinking guide worksheets, and club discussions are designed to work together to gear students toward comprehending club concepts.
- Club sessions are designed to encourage students to make connections between provided information and their own developing ideas.
- The F & M Club addresses heavy interconnected issues such as sexism, sexual objectification, gender roles, effects of sexism on men, rape, and prostitution.
- By providing a safe and fun environment the F & M Club will facilitate student’s ability to look beyond morbid issues. Instead, student’s primary focus will be directed toward drawing analytical bridges in relating club discussions to real life.
- Students will be encouraged to question issues and its significance to the real world in order to understand issues as problematic matters.
- Student’s comprehension of the overall objective behind essential questions is fundamental in reaching club goals.
- Questions are designed to complicate student’s thoughts and to encourage them to think beyond club topics and to make analytical connections.
- For example: Can everyone’s personalities and attitudes fit within socially constructed gender roles?
- In answering this question students will be able to put their own personalities and attitudes into perspective and realize that perhaps gender roles are meant to be overstepped.
- One of the most defining goals of the F & M Club is to help students achieve, through their own learning process, a healthier and more accurate understanding of femininity and masculinity.
- Through this process students will be able to gain a clearer understanding of who they are as individuals, apart from socially constructed gender roles.
- By acknowledging the limitations of gender roles, students will be better equipped to question portrayals of sexuality in the media as well as in everyday life.
- Aware of the mass media exposure that high school are susceptible to on a daily basis, the F & M club works to provide critical lens through which students can make judgments in identifying negative or positive media messages.
- The F & M Club is composed of lesson plans, that accumulative, creates a learning experience that can be beneficial to students across school districts, cultures, and experiences. Therefore, as long as students have access to media, student can find benefits in joining the F & M Club.
- Moreover, while in the process of making connections students will also be encouraged to engage in class discussions, thus sharpening their communications skills.
- By cultivating essential skills, the F & M club can serve multidimensional purpose while maintaining its focus on sexism and other gender related issues.
Assessment of the F & M Club:
- Club success will be measured by student’s ability to demonstrate understanding of club concepts.
- Club leaders should look for improvements in speech and communication skills as well as students ability to reference back to previously discussed topics and issues.
- Students should express their ability to understand issues discussed in club meetings as problematic interconnected topics that may derive from sexism and construction of gender roles.
- Overall students should demonstrate ability to make connections and build bridges in their understanding of sexism, sexual objectification gender roles, rape and prostitution.
- Students should become more willing to participate in club activities and discussions.
- Club activities and club discussion performance is essential in establishing a relationship between students and club leader.
- This relationship will serve as a guide in determining what concepts students may be struggling with therefore providing club leaders with clues in determining what lessons may need redefining.
Session 1: Discussion of Femininity and Masculinity
Lesson Goals:
- Get students to think about the ways in which they understand femininity and masculinity.
- Help them reach the realization that not everyone fits perfectly into what has been socially constructed for their particular gender.
Essential Question: Can everyone’s personalities and attitudes fit within socially constructed gender roles? Student Objectives:
- Students will be able to view gender roles as socially constructed ideas.
- Students will demonstrate the ability to question gender roles and social expectations.
- Students will acknowledge that not everyone fits into narrowed gender roles.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion:
- Hand out Gender and Personality Trait Worksheet for completion
- Discussion of Gender and Personality Worksheet:
- How closely do these personality traits resemble you as a female/male?
- Do you have personality traits that were mentioned for the opposite gender?
- Can boys have feminine qualities and girls masculine qualities?
- Further Discussion of Gender and Personality Trait Worksheet:
- Collect assignments and ask for four volunteers (preferably a mix between male and female students).
- Randomly hand each volunteer a personality trait assignment from one of their peers and have volunteer read the list out loud.
- Ask students to guess whether the list was written by a female or male peer.
Learning Plan:
- This worksheet is designed to work as an icebreaker for the club and will allow for interactions between the students in order to create a comfortable learning environment.
- Students will learn from each other’s response.
Contents and Resources:
- Gender and Personality Traits Worksheet
(Note: gender personality trait worksheets are available on the internet or through your school counselor )
- A discussion of worksheet
Session 2: Femininity and Masculinity in Music Videos
Lesson Goals:
Get students to think expansively about the ways in which music videos may encourage positive and negative representations of femininity and masculinity
Essential Question: In what ways can music videos provide a negative representation of gender? Student Objectives:
- Students should be able to consider the ways in which music videos may objectify or devalue women.
- Recognize that music videos may provide a misrepresentation of men and women.
- Students should be able to consider the ways in which music videos may portray men as dominant figures in aggressive roles.
Learning Activity:
- Music Video Discussion
- Hand out Thinking Guides:
- What personality traits can you assign to the females in the music video?
- What personality traits can you assign to the males in the music video?
- Do you think this music video provides an accurate representation of each gender? Why or why not?
- What is masculinity according to this music video?
- What is femininity according to this music video?
|
Learning Plan:
- Provide current relatable music videos.
- Give students tools to better understand the portrayal of femininity and masculinity in music videos
Contents and Resources:
- Snoop Dog – Drop it Like it’s Hot – Thinking guide
- Snoop Dog – Drop it Like it’s Hot – Link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtUVQei3nX4
- Snoop Dog – Drop it Like it’s Hot – Lyrics
- The Pussycat Dolls ft. Williams – Beep – Thinking guide
- The Pussycat Dolls ft. Williams – Beep – Link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1r9ghI7YcL0
- The Pussycat Dolls ft. Williams – Beep – Lyrics
Preparations for next club meeting:
Have students bring an advertisement that raises a sexist issue.
Session 3: Inequality in Advertisements
Lesson Goals:
Students will be exposed to an advertisement that subordinates the male gender encouraging students to take on a different perspective in their quest to understanding sexism.
Essential Question: In what ways can advertisement encourage inequality and sexism? Student Objectives:
- Demonstrate active criticism.
- Students should be able to communicate their ideas and opinions.
- Demonstrate ability to make connections in order to form an opinion.
Learning Activity/Club Exercise:
Discussion of advertisements:
- Have students briefly discuss the issue they found in the advertisement piece of their choice.
- What issues does this advertisement raise?
- Is it more of a women’s or man’s problem?
Voodoo Winter Hosiery Advertisement Worksheet:
- Did you find this advertisement offensive? Why or why not?
- Would it make any difference if roles were reversed and a man was holding the leash instead? Why?
- Is there any irony in this advertisement?
- Is there any symbolism in this advertisement?
Learning Plan:
- Make students slightly uncomfortable with issues related to inequality, encouraging students to question its components and significance.
- Encourage students to look beyond images to find meaning.
- Encourage active criticism as well as provide insights to real complaints and outcomes.
Contents and Resources:
Voodoo Winter Hosiery Advertisement Worksheet
The ad is available on the internet, but it might just be better to describe it to your students – it features a woman from the torso down walking two naked men on leashes.
Session 4: Complicating Femininity and Masculinity in Cartoons
Lesson Goals:
- Expose students to real issues related to gender and have them think critically about sexism, inequality, double standard, and the objectification of women.
- The purpose of this lesson is to provide a more concrete base knowledge for students.
Essential Question: What gender related issues can you find in political cartoons? Student Objectives:
Gain a better understanding of why issues such sexism, inequality, double standard, and the objectification of women are problematic.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion:
Cartoon Worksheet Groups :
- Break the class into seven groups and assign each group a cartoon worksheet
- Each group will tackle different topics related to gender roles and sexism.
- Encourage class participation.
- How do you feel about this issue?
- Is it more of a women or a man’s problem?
- Why do you think this has become an issue?
- How could you argue against this issue?
|
Learning Plan:
- Use humorous cartoons to expose students to real issues.
- Students will learn from each other’s response.
- Practice team communication skills.
- Create fun environment.
Contents and Resources:
Teachers can create this worksheet by searching the internet for cartoons about the seven topics listed below and printing the think guide questions below them.
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Construction of Gender Roles
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Over Sexualized Women in Media
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Women and Relationships
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Questioning Sexism
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Degrading Women
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Misinterpretations
- Cartoon Thinking Guide – Objectification of Women
Session 5: Masculinity and Sexism
Lesson Goals:
This lesson is designed to make students aware of the ways in which sexism may affect both genders.
Essential Question: In what ways can sexism affect men? Student Objectives:
Students should be able to take on a more critical perspective on gender roles, relationship advice, and the expectations placed on men.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion/Club Exercise:
How Sexism Hurts Men: “Undateable”
- What are do’s and don’ts for men?
- What advice do parents tend to give their male children?
- What kind of expectations do the media and society place on men?
Sexism, Strength and Dominance: Masculinity in Disney Films
- Hand out Masculinity in Disney Films Thinking Guide
- Have students read through questions before playing video on projector.
- Go over questions on Thinking Guide and encourage class participation.
Learning Plan:
- Provide relatable information.
- Students will learn from each other’s response.
Contents and Resources:
- How Sexism Hurt Men: “Undateable” discussion
- The Sexism, Strength and Dominance: Masculinity in Disney Films – YouTube link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8CWMCt35oFY
- The Sexism, Strength and Dominance: Masculinity in Disney Films – Thinking Guide
(Note: Masculinity in Disney Films is a popular topic on the internet. We suggest reading several of the short essays and making your own thinking guide from them .)
Session 6: Advertising Rape
Lesson Goals:
The purpose of this lesson is to encourage students to make connections between the portrayal of sexuality in the media and the real world.
Essential Question: What connections can you make between the portrayal of sexuality in advertisements and rape? Student Objectives:
- Students should be able to reflect and make connections between the Richmond Gang Rape news piece and the Dolce and Gabbana thinking guide.
- Demonstrate improvements in ability to communicate ideas.
- Show more confidence in partaking in class discussion and in expressing opinions.
- Students should be able to consider the ways in which advertisements may portray men as dominant figures in aggressive roles.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion:
Richmond Gang Rape News Piece :
- Who were the attackers?
- The attackers dominated and used their strength towards the victim; can you describe their actions as a form of aggressively expressing their masculinity?
Dolce and Gabbana Thinking Guide :
- What is going on in this advertisement?
- Does this image glorify rape? Why?
- In what ways can this type of advertisement affect the ways in which people understand interpersonal relationships? Why?
Learning Plan:
- Students will learn from each other’s response.
- Connect club issues with real news.
Contents and Resources:
- Richmond Gang Rape 911 Caller Speaks: Margarita Vargas Heard About Attack, Reported It – Huffpost Los Angeles
- Dolce and Gabbana Thinking Guide
(Note: this offensive ad is also available on the internet, but again we suggest just telling students that a famous designer label uses rape scenes to sell product and ask their opinions. )
Session 7: Sexual Objectification
Lesson Goals:
Understand sexual objectification as a problematic issue that encourages inequality by portraying women as sex objects devoid of personality, sentience, and other human characteristics.
Essential Question: In what ways can women be sexually objectified? Student Objectives:
- Understand that there is more to a situation then what is openly exposed.
- Students should demonstrate ability to assign human characteristics and emotions to objectified women.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion: The Harlem Dancer
by Claude McKay:
- How does this poem make you feel?
- Why do you think the dancer in this poem is working in this nightclub?
The Harlem Dancer
Critical Essay:
- According to the critical essay, what is the difference between the dancer’s public and private self?
- How does the speaker view the dancer?
- How does the audience view the dancer?
- How is the dancer sexuality objectified?
Learning Plan:
- Sharpen student’s ability to analyze and read poetry in order to further develop their critical thinking skills.
- Broaden student’s perspectives.
Contents and Resources:
- The Harlem Dancer by Claude McKay
- The Harlem Dancer Critical Essay by Arelis Ruiz
Session 8: A Look into Prostitution and Sex Work
Lesson Goals:
Understand prostitution as a system that objectifies women by making them objects of sexual pleasure.
Essential Questions:
- In what ways are sex workers objectified?
- What challenges do sex workers face?
Student Objectives:
- Students should continue to demonstrate ability to assign human characteristics and emotions to objectified women.
- Understand that many sex workers are manipulated into prostitution through psychological, physical, and financial pressure.
- Understand that many sex workers may view their job occupation as empowering.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion:
A Way out of Prostitution
- Why do you think sex workers are at such high risk for sexual and physical abuse?
- Why would an assaulter think its ok to rape a prostitute?
- What type of external pressures may keep sex worker unable to break away from this lifestyle?
Who’re You Calling a Whore? A Conversation with three Sex Workers on Sexuality, Empowerment, and the Industry
:
- In what ways, according to the article, can sex work be viewed as empowering?
- What arguments can you find against this idea of empowerment?
- Were you surprised by this article?
Learning Plan:
Broaden student’s perspectives.
Contents and Resources:
- Star Tribune: A Way out of Prostitution by Pat Pheifer
- Who’re You Calling a Whore? A Conversation with three Sex Workers on Sexuality Empowerment, and the Industry by Susan Lopez, Mariko Passion, Saundra
Session 9: Club Visitor
Note from LessonPlansPage.com:
Be very careful with this session. Check references from other school districts or clubs that this speaker has appeared at. Be sure to get approval from parents/guardians, principal, and school board.
Lesson Goals:
Expose students to real people who have dealt, in one way or another, with the effects of sexual objectification, and/or sexism.
Essential Questions:
- In what ways are sex workers objectified?
- What challenges do sex workers face?
Student Objectives:
- Students should demonstrate ability to understand concepts/challenges discussed by visitor.
- Students should demonstrate ability to make connections between previously discussed issues and concepts/challenges discussed by visitor.
- Take part in providing a comfortable environment for visitor.
Learning Activity/ Visitor:
“Jane Doe” – Exotic Dancer
Learning Plan:
Provide students with an unforgettable learning experience.
Contents and Resources:
Signed testimony of “Jane Doe” experience as an exotic dancer.
- This testimony is not to be distributed to club.
- Club leaders should use this testimony as an informative outline of what “Jane Doe” will be discussing.
Preparations for next club meeting:
- Ask students to bring an image of a role model that take on or express healthy, admirable, and/or respected feminine or masculine qualities.
- This role model can be a family member, friend, celebrity, historical figure, teacher, or any other person or figure.
Session 10: Redefining Femininity and Masculinity
Lesson Goals:
Help students established a healthy definition of femininity and masculinity.
Essential Questions:
- How would you define masculinity?
- How would you define femininity?
Student Objectives:
- Students should demonstrate ability to create their own unique definition of femininity and masculinity.
- Students should demonstrate confidence in their definitions.
Learning Activity/Club Discussion/Club Exercise:
Role Model:
- How does this person take or express healthy, admirable, and/or respected feminine or masculine qualities?
- Do you see this person as a healthy role model for children? Why?
Redefining Femininity and Masculinity:
- As a class, come up with a new and unique definition for femininity and masculinity that everyone can feel proud of.
Learning Plan:
- Create fun environment.
- Create a memorable moment.
|
|
-
Share
-
Save
- Print
- E-mail
- PDF
- Comment
- Report
Rate: