Title – Comparing Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Respiration

By – Amy Malowitz

Primary Subject – Science

Grade Level – 7-10

Objective:

• Students will compare the two types of cellular respiration: aerobic respiration and anaerobic respiration (fermentation). Students will note similarities and differences between the two processes including when, where, and how each process occurs.

• Students will develop a concept map using Inspiration indicating the criteria for aerobic and anaerobic respiration. This concept map will indicate:
  • Three similarities between the two processes.
    
  • Two types of cells that perform each process.
    
  • Location in the cell where each process occurs.
    
  • Oxygen requirements for each process.
    
  • Reactants and products for each process.
    
  • Energy output for each process.
    
  • Two different types of anaerobic respiration.
    • Reactants and products for each.
      
    • Types of cells that perform each process.

Introduction:

• This activity will follow a fermentation (anaerobic respiration) lab using yeast. This lab will address the process of alcoholic fermentation.
  
• Students will perform push-ups to experience lactic acid build-up in muscle cells.
  
• These activities will gain interest in the process of anaerobic respiration.
  
• Students will have already studied the detailed process of aerobic cellular respiration.

Procedure:

• Students will work in pairs or trios to answer questions (as seen in benchmarks) on aerobic and anaerobic respiration.
  
• Students will use previous notes and lab activities to summarize main ideas for aerobic and anaerobic respiration.
  
• Individually, students will create a concept map using Inspiration to further integrate and separate the two processes.

Accommodations:

• Instructions will be provided in written format as well as read orally. Instructions will also be on an overhead.
  
• One example will be provided for students on how to summarize data.
  
• Students will be shown examples of concept maps.
  
• Individual groups will have to show completed summary before proceeding to complete concept map.
  
• Students will be asked to draw a part of their concept map on paper before proceeding to computer to ensure understanding of procedure.

E-Mail

Amy Malowitz

!